| 1870 | Edward Parker | 1915-1916 | Charles L. Lee | 1959-1960 | Arthur H. Jean |
| 1871 | Albert H. Saunders | 1917-1918 | Walter B. Nute | *1961-1962 | Richard G. Tenney |
| 1872 | Martin V. B. Greene | 1919-1920 | George H. Parker | 1963-1964 | Thomas J. Foster |
| 1873-1874 | Hermon F. Dane | 1921-1922 | Charles A. Strange | 1965-1966 | Horace L. Knights |
| 1875 | Joshua W. Hunt | 1923-1924 | Alfred K. Nickols | 1967-1968 | Raymond P. Chaloner |
| 1876-1877 | Addison Knight | 1925-1926 | Allen B. Andrews | 1969-1971 | Harry C. Downing Jr. |
| 1878 | George E. Spaulding | 1927 | Harold F. Tupper | *1972 | John A. Martin |
| 1879-1880 | George B. Bowler | 1928-1929 | Roland B. Burnham | 1973-1974 | Bradford L. Cross |
| 1881-1882 | Charles H. Webster | 1930-1931 | Edward S. Lyon | 1975-1976 | George Mitchell III |
| 1883-1884 | Winfield S. Stetson | 1932 | Clarence H. Wright | 1977 | George G. Howland |
| 1885-1886 | Sidney H. Favor | 1933-1934 | Sumner D. Webster | 1978-1979 | Vern M. Hoffmaster |
| 1887 | Joseph Shattuck | 1935 | Sidney F. Baker | *1980-1981 | Walter D. Alcox Jr. |
| 1888-1989 | Frank W. Adams | 1936 | Arlon W. Jennison | *1982-1983 | William W. Gould |
| 1890-1891 | Hendrick B. Gordon | 1937 | George A. Gardner | *1984 | Donald R. Crerie |
| 1892 | Charles H. Webster | 1938 | Maurice H. Whidden | *1985 | Arthur L. Hebert |
| 1893-1894 | Edward O. Fifield | 1939-1940 | Vaughan W. Pearson | *1986 | Benjamin Feldman |
| 1895-1896 | Edward P. Graham | 1941 | John D. Spring MD | *1987 | Donald R. Crerie |
| 1897-1898 | Robert Leighton | 1942 | Chester J. Bradley | *1988-1989 | Everett A. Crosscup |
| 1899-1900 | John A. Lyon | 1943-1944 | Elvin B. Haynes OD | *1990-1991 | Augustus H. Rice Jr. |
| 1901-1902 | George E. Richardson | 1945-1946 | Leighton E. White | *1992-1993 | Thomas S. Lowe |
| 1903-1904 | Charles H. Austin | 1947-1948 | Maurice V. Buckley | 1994-1995 | Edward Wainwright Sr |
| 1905-1906 | Henry C. Shattuck | 1949-1950 | Samuel L. Coronis | *1996-1997 | Gerard P. Leduc |
| 1907-1908 | Horace E. Osgood | 1951-1952 | James H. Bardsley | *1998-1999 | Mark W. Leavitt |
| 1909-1910 | George W. Parsons | 1953-1954 | George G. Howland | *2000-2001 | Stephen K. Bashler |
| 1911-1912 | Henry W. Webster | 1955-1956 | Frederick Goodwin Jr | *2002-2003 | Andrew R. Hall |
| 1913-1914 | Henry A. Twitchell | 1957-1958 | Harold W. Holt | *2004-2005 | Robert A. Baer |
| *2006-2007 | Edmund E. Correa | ||||
| *Currently Living Past Masters | |||||